Jesus: Friend, you have asked one of the oldest questions the human heart carries. It is the question of Job in the ash-heap, of the Preacher in Jerusalem, of the crowd who came running to me with news of blood spilled in the temple. It has never been a small question, and I will not treat it as one. Let me begin where the writer of Lamentations begins, sitting in the rubble of a city he loved. He asks, aloud and unflinching, Do not both adversity and good come from the mouth of the Most High? Notice — he does not resolve the mystery. He names it. He refuses the easy comfort of pretending that only the sweet things come from God and the bitter things from somewhere else. The world is not so tidy. The same sky sends rain on the field of the just and the field of the unjust, and the same sky sometimes withholds it. To love God honestly is to sit with that, not around it. And yet the human heart wants a ledger. We want the arithmetic to work. Job's friends wanted it desperately — surely disaster comes to the wicked, and only to them. Does not disaster come to the unjust and calamity to the workers of iniquity? It is a reasonable-sounding question, and it is the very question the whole book of Job spends forty chapters dismantling. Because Job himself is righteous. His suffering is not payment for a hidden sin. His friends' arithmetic is wrong, and God says so plainly at the end. The ledger you are looking for — the one where good people are safe and bad people suffer — does not exist in the shape you want it to. Job saw this with his own eyes and could not unsee it. Why do the wicked live on, growing old and increasing in power? There it is, spoken aloud in Scripture — the scandal that will not leave us. The cruel prosper. The tender are crushed. Children die. Kind women get sick. Gentle men are betrayed. And meanwhile the ones who trade in cruelty seem to sleep well and wake to more. If you have ever felt this in your chest and wondered whether you were allowed to feel it — you were. Job did. The Scripture holds his complaint without rebuke. The Preacher in Ecclesiastes saw the same thing and gave it a name. There is a futility that is done on the earth: there are righteous men who get what the actions of the wicked deserve, and there are wicked men who get what the actions of the righteous deserve. I say that this too is futile. Futility. Vapor. Breath. The Preacher does not solve it either. He names it as one of the hard, true things about living under the sun. And I think there is a mercy in that naming. When Scripture itself refuses the neat answer, you are freed from the burden of manufacturing one. There was a day when some came to me with news of Galileans whose blood Pilate had mingled with their sacrifices — a horror, a violence at worship itself. And the unspoken question behind their telling was the same as yours. Were those people worse? Did they have it coming? Do you think that these Galileans were worse sinners than all the other Galileans, because they suffered this way? I said no. I said it plainly. Suffering is not a scoreboard. The tower that fell at Siloam did not fall because those eighteen were guiltier than their neighbors. The world is not so simple, and God is not so small. So what remains, when the ledger is set aside? A few things, I think, and I offer them softly. The first is that God is not absent from the suffering, even when God is not the author of every wound. I did not stay at a safe distance from human pain. I entered it. I wept at a tomb. I bled on a hill. Whatever answer you are given about suffering, let it be an answer that has room for a God who suffers alongside — not a God who watches from far off with a spreadsheet. The second is that goodness is not a shield, and it was never promised to be. The saints have known this. Job knew it. The prophets knew it. To be good is not to be exempt; it is to be faithful in a world where exemption is not on offer. There is a strange dignity in that — a goodness that does not require reward to remain itself. The third is that the question you are asking is holy. Do not let anyone shame you out of it. Scripture asks it on nearly every page. God is not afraid of it. Sit with it. Bring it. Weep it, if you need to. I will not hand you a tidy resolution, because I do not think one exists this side of the veil, and I will not pretend otherwise. But I will sit with you in the asking. That, at least, I can promise. What is it, in your own life, that brought this question to your lips today?

This conversation was had on BibleJesus — Talk with Jesus yourself — free on iOS ✝️